Phoenix woman on the hook for $45K after falling ill on ‘dream’ cruise — why travel insurance denied her claim

Story by Jessica Wong

 • 9h • 

5 min read

Phoenix woman's dream trip becomes $45K nightmare

Phoenix woman’s dream trip becomes $45K nightmare© Arizona’s Family News

Pat Wuensche and her family are seasoned travelers. So when they found a two-part cruise, Los Angeles to Japan, then Singapore back to the U.S., they jumped at the opportunity to go on the 72-day cruise.

At the time of booking, their travel agent offered insurance and Wuensche didn’t hesitate.Durable Custom License Plates - Shop Now At Vistaprint

Ad

vistaprint.comDurable Custom License Plates – Shop Now At Vistaprint

Learn More

“I thought, ‘We’re going to be gone a long time,’” she told Arizona’s Family News, “‘we better cover ourselves.’ So I went ahead and paid for it on both trips, just as a precaution.”

Don’t miss

Unfortunately, the safety net vanished when they needed it most. Now, they’re left with a little more than $45,000 in uncovered expenses, despite having paid for a policy they thought would protect them.Related video: Travel medical insurance policies can be affordable and convenient if you shop around (WMUR Manchester)

Sandra Gutierrez faced a health emergency while attending a destination

Current Time 0:02

/

Duration 2:01

WMUR Manchester

Travel medical insurance policies can be affordable and convenient if you shop around

0

View on Watch

A $45,000 shock

Wuensche fell ill and was hospitalized once the family arrived in Japan.

“So, [the doctor] said, ‘How long can I keep you in the hospital?’ And I said, ‘How about one day?’” Wuensche said. “And he said, ‘No, you need to cancel the whole rest of your trip.’”

The second cruise was canceled, and Wuensche spent a total of 57 days in the hospital.

“The doctors knew very few [English] words,” she said. “When they first discovered it was COVID, I was put in isolation so my family couldn’t even visit. I was really in isolation. It was tough.”

Wuensche knew the bills would be steep, but she felt reassured by the insurance she’d purchased.

When she got home, Wuensche filed a claim with Aon, the company affiliated with the cruise line.

Instead of reimbursement, Wuensche says she faced months of silence and repeated requests for more documents.

“It is frustrating because you think you can go there with peace of mind knowing if something happens, you’re OK,” she said. “And unfortunately for us, something happened.”5 Best Home Warranty Companies - Compare Companies Side-by-Side

Ad

besthomewarrantyonline.com5 Best Home Warranty Companies – Compare Companies Side-by-Side

Learn More

After months of back and forth, Aon responded. According to the company, Wuensche’s policy only covered her cruise, not the medical emergency that caused her to cancel it.

They agreed to cover the $8,000 cruise cancellation fee, but not the $45,000-plus in hospital and hotel costs.

“It should be covered. Absolutely,” Wuensche said.

The policy did save the family from cruise cancellation penalties, but it left them on the hook for the much larger cost: the actual medical emergency.

It’s a tough lesson in the realities of travel insurance.

Travel insurance can be quite specific, and even a slight change in your itinerary can make your coverage null and void.

Read more: You don’t have to be a millionaire to gain access to this $1B private real estate fund. In fact, you can get started with as little as $10 — here’s how

The fine print travelers can miss

For millions of Americans, like Wuensche, travel insurance feels like peace of mind.

According to Hotel News Resource, the number of paid claims for travel delays grew by 15% in 2024, with average payouts rising by 8% compared to 2023. The most common claims were emergency medical ones — for the first time in more than a decade — making up 27% of all paid claims.Atlanta News Archives - Billions of Records Online

Ad

genealogybank.comAtlanta News Archives – Billions of Records Online

Learn More

However, insurance can feel like a maze of fine print, exclusions and technical loopholes that most travelers only likely discover after their claims are denied.

Wuensche assumed that since she had purchased insurance for the duration of the trip, she’d be protected regardless of what happened. But based on the terms and conditions, once the second part of the trip was “canceled,” all other benefits, including medical coverage, were terminated.

How to avoid a financial meltdown on vacation

Want to avoid being the next headline? Here are some travel insurance tips to keep in mind.

First, buy your insurance early, ideally, right after booking. Waiting too long can exclude you from coverage for unforeseen events, like storms or labor strikes.

Second, read your entire policy and not just the summary. Pay attention to cancellation rules, limits on coverage and what triggers termination of benefits. Don’t assume that because you’re on a trip, you’re still covered. As in this case, policies can end medical protection the moment your travel status changes.

Third, ask direct questions before buying. Will I be covered if I cancel midtrip? What if I’m hospitalized in another country? Do I need to file through my health insurance first? Get the answers in writing if possible.

Finally, don’t assume your credit card or employer-provided insurance will fill the gap. Those benefits can be secondary and cover only what is not paid for by a primary insurance plan.

The Wuensche family’s $45,000 ordeal is more than just a travel horror story; it’s a cautionary tale for every traveler who’s ever clicked “add insurance” without doing their due diligence.

What to read next

Money doesn’t have to be complicated — sign up for the free Moneywise newsletter for actionable finance tips and news you can use. Join now.

This article provides information only and should not be construed as advice. It is provided without warranty of any kind.Return Assurance, $10.79 / You Can Return Any Eligible Final Sale Items In Your Order For A Refund

Return Assurance, $10.79 / You Can Return Any Eligible Final Sale Items In Your Order For A Refund

Ad

Eric Javits

Visit Moneywise

‘This was a principle thing’: Colorado man fights back after emergency hospital stay results in $104K bill

This Tennessee janitor went from living in his car to driving a $3 million Bugatti — here’s how he invested

‘Recipe for disaster’: Tony Robbins blasts US retirees for relying on Social Security — how to avoid the trap

Sponsored Content

Local Mercedes Deals - Best Offers In Your Area

mercedesbenzpricequotes.com

Local Mercedes Deals – Best Offers In Your Area

Sponsored

more

Find Old Obituaries Online - Largest Obituary Archive Bank

genealogybank.com

Find Old Obituaries Online – Largest Obituary Archive Bank

Sponsored

more

Atlanta News Archives - Billions of Records Online

genealogybank.com

Atlanta News Archives – Billions of Records Online

Sponsored

more

More for You

1-year-old killed instantly after family pit bull bit into baby’s neck

The IndependentThe Independent

·10h

1-year-old killed instantly after family pit bull bit into baby’s neck

Delta flight makes emergency landing after lithium battery explodes in passenger’s carry-on

The IndependentThe Independent

·9h

Delta flight makes emergency landing after lithium battery explodes in passenger’s carry-on

Mechanics Agree: Extended Auto Warranty Only Worthwhile If Your Car Brand Is This

GoWizard

Mechanics Agree: Extended Auto Warranty Only Worthwhile If Your Car Brand Is This

Sponsored

more

'Free money' from Trump accounts is a 'no-brainer,' says expert—but other options may be better

CNBCCNBC

·13h

‘Free money’ from Trump accounts is a ‘no-brainer,’ says expert—but other options may be better

Norwegian Cruises cancels 4 months of sailings. Here are the itineraries impacted

The IndependentThe Independent

·13h

Norwegian Cruises cancels 4 months of sailings. Here are the itineraries impacted

Texas sheriff who predicted floods says lives could have been saved

Daily MailDaily Mail

·11h

Texas sheriff who predicted floods says lives could have been saved

I'm 72 years old, healthy, retired for 5 years and completely bored with my life — I want to go back to work but no one wants to hire me because of my age. What can I do?

MoneywiseMoneywise

I’m 72 years old, healthy, retired for 5 years and completely bored with my life — I want to go back to work but no one wants to hire me because of my age. What can I do?

President Trump Orders National Parks to Raise Fees on International Visitors

OutsideOutside

·16h

President Trump Orders National Parks to Raise Fees on International Visitors

headphone stoped
share
more

Charleston WCSC-TV

11.9K Followers

Lowcountry family among thousands nationwide facing home warranty headaches

Story by Katie Kamin, Michael Allison

 • 1w • 

4 min read

A Lowcountry family's frustrating experience with Choice Home Warranty mirrors thousands of complaints nationwide about denied repairs, delays and confusing fine print.

A Lowcountry family’s frustrating experience with Choice Home Warranty mirrors thousands of complaints nationwide about denied repairs, delays and confusing fine print.© Live 5

HANAHAN, S.C. (WCSC) – Buying a home is one of the biggest investments most people will ever make, and for many, a home warranty seems like a layer of protection.

But dozens of South Carolinians and thousands more across the country say one popular warranty company hasn’t lived up to that promise.

Live 5 Investigates uncovered thousands of complaints filed against Choice Home Warranty, revealing a pattern of delays, denied claims and unmet expectations.

Josh Birch is one of the customers behind those complaints.

He and his wife bought their home in Hanahan in 2021. Wanting to protect the investment, they signed up for a long-term home warranty with Choice Home Warranty, largely because of concerns about the home’s aging HVAC system, he says.

Current Time 0:00

/

Duration 6:19

Charleston WCSC-TV

VIDEO: Lowcountry family among thousands nationwide facing home warranty headaches

0

View on Watch

Minor problems, like a fridge seal or faulty dishwasher, were fixed without issue. When their air conditioner and ductwork needed replacing, however, things fell apart, Birch says.

“When it comes time for them to do what they’re supposed to do on their end, they’re like, ‘Nope, sorry, that’s excluded,’” he says. “If you exclude everything, is the house really covered?”Expand article logo  Continue reading

Choice Home Warranty failed to send a technician, forcing him to find one himself, he says. The claim was denied within minutes of submitting the estimate.

After a frustrating appeals process, Birch was left with a $16,000 bill for a new air conditioner, he says. He’s still waiting to replace the ductwork, which he estimates could cost another $10,000 to $13,000.

Visit Charleston WCSC-TV

Berkeley Electric Cooperative to receive $250K in funding from Google

New center providing life-saving resources, training opens in Goose Creek

Classroom Champions: New Lowcountry teacher needs activities to stock classroom

Sponsored Content

More for You

Leave a comment